Categories
Climate Change Law Climate Change Lawsuits Climate Change Litigation Paris Agreement

OBLIGATIONS OF PRIVATE ENTERPRISES TOWARDS THE PARIS AGREEMENT: THE LANDMARK DECISION OF A NETHERLANDS COURT

This article analyses a judgment of a Netherlands court (that ordered a private company to comply with the objectives of the Paris AgreementNabil Iqbal & Syeda Mehar Ejaz are law students from Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi, India.) with special emphasis on the grounds on which the judgment has been delivered and its significance in the contemporary world. Written by Nabil Iqbal & Syeda Mehar Ejaz, law students from Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi, India.

The district court of Netherlands on May 26, 2021 pronounced a judgment in MILIEUDEFENSIE ET AL. V. ROYAL DUTCH SHELL PLC that orders the Royal Dutch Shell (RDS), a leading oil manufacturer, to cut its carbon emission by 45% (from its 2019 level) by the year 2030. The decision has been applauded by the environmental activists who have remarked it as a landmark judgment in the domain of environmental litigation.

The case was filed in April 2019 by several Dutch NGOs and more than 17,000 individual co-claimants against the Royal Dutch Shell (RDS), requesting a declaratory judgment against the RDS for its failure to obligate with the target of net zero carbon emission by 2050, which was set as the objective to reach the goal of Paris Agreement that has been ratified by various countries including the Netherlands. The allegations made by the claimants were based on the report mentioned in the RDS website that states the company’s current aim of 20% reduction in carbon emission by 2030, which is less than the global set level of 45%.

The court after analyzing the allegations, directed the RDS to reduce its carbon emission as per the global limit on the basis of the following observations –

Duty of CareThe court observed that RDS owes a duty of care towards the citizens as per the provisions of unwritten standard of care mentioned in Book 6 Section 162 of Dutch Civil Code. This provision marks the activities which is contrary to the rule of unwritten law pertaining to proper social conduct as unlawful. RDS failure to consider the duty of care towards its citizen while making its policies has been considered as one such activity. The court also discusses the UN Guiding Principles (UNGP) on business and human rights, which talks about the role of businesses and states towards the human rights. Analyzing both the provisions, the court held that the RDS policy of 20% carbon emission reduction, which is less than the global set level of 45%, is contrary to the provision of standard of care of Dutch Civil Code. Further, the court observed that RDS owes a larger individual duty of care since it is one of the major carbon emitters of the world and its emission has more impact on climate change than some of the countries.

Violation of Human Rights – Right to Life of Individual and his family have been recognized in the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights (Articles 2 and 8) and International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (Articles 6 and 17). Further, rulings of Urgenda v. The state of Netherlands;  López Ostra v Spain; Őneryildiz v Turkey and the UN Human Rights Committee discussion on the global warming expressly states that global warming as a consequence of carbon emission amounts to violation of the above provisions of ECHR and UDHR. Applying both these observations, the court held the RDS failure to comply with the global set level of reduction as a violation of ECHR and ICCPR. On the question whether these provisions are applied to private corporations, the court relies on the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, which states that businesses owe an obligation to protect human rights.

The judgement is considered as a landmark due to various reasons. Firstly, it is for the first time that a private enterprise has been ordered to comply with the targets of the Paris agreement. Previously, in urgenda foundation case and Neubauer, et al. v. Germany, the court has ordered the states to comply with the zero-carbon emission target, but it is for the first time that a private enterprise has been ordered to do so. Secondly, it will set a precedent for other countries to mandate the large businesses to comply with the target of zero carbon emission. However, the judgment does not have any authoritative value, but the decision demonstrates a benchmark for obligations on emissions reductions and analysis of norms related to human rights and IEL. Peculiar to the Netherlands, the decision would positively increase the class of actions before the different courts for seeking climate justice on the grounds of human rights violations pursuing damages for detriments caused by excessive emissions.

Categories
Climate Change Law Climate Change Laws Around the World Climate Change Legislation Climate Crisis Legal Regulation Paris Agreement

The U.S. Falls Behind Majority of the World in Reducing CO2 Emissions: The Case for Rejoining the Paris Agreement.

Climate Change Law American Paris Agreement Biden

By Alexandra Lauren Horn, Esq., a U.S. Attorney, admitted to the Bar in New York and New Jersey, with a Certificate in International Law and an interest in Environmental Law and Human Rights. Note you can also download this article as a Word Document or PDF with full footnotes/endnotes below the post.

On November 4, 2020, while most of the world was obsessively watching the growing vote count between President Donald Trump and Democratic Presidential Nominee Joe Biden, the U.S. formally withdrew from the 2015 Paris Agreement.[i]

Categories
Climate Change Law Climate Change Legislation Climate Change Regulations

Will the Heat Networks Bill warm up the District Heating Sector in Scotland ?

Heat-Networks-Bill-warm-up-the-District-Heating-Sector-in-Scotland
The Scottish Government has committed to a 35% reduction in carbon emissions from heating domestic properties by 2032 and a reduction in carbon emissions from heating non-domestic properties of 70% by 2032. In this post, Solicitor and 2050 Climate Group volunteer Alex Irwin explains some of the significant challenges in decarbonising heat, a number of notable aspects of the Heat Networks Bill in Scotland and the need for more legislation pertaining to sustainable heat.

The carbon emissions from heating domestic homes account for around 13% of the UK’s annual carbon emissions. The carbon emissions from heating homes is comparable to the contribution of all petrol and diesel cars in the UK. 

Categories
Climate Change Law

Top 100 Legal Blogs on Environmental Law

Feedspot are putting together a list of their top 100 environmental law blogs here. We’re grateful for them to include us and if you can suggest any others for them to add please do so.

Categories
Climate Change Law

Top 35+ Climate Change Law Influencers to Follow on Twitter

The following are some of the top climate change legal influencers on Twitter. They are some of the best lawyers, legal academics and legal organisations trying to turn the tide on climate change through change in the law across many different jurisdictions.

Categories
Climate Change Law

The [Chancery Lane] Project is Re-wiring Contracts and Laws to fight Climate Change

Thanks to Lynette Purves for highlighting this to me some time ago, the [Chancery Lane] Project is doing some incredible work in helping to re-wire contracts and create model laws to enable communities and businesses to fight climate change.

Categories
Climate Change Law Climate Change Law & Policy Climate Crisis Legal Regulation

What Is Climate Change Law?

Climate change law encompasses the policies and regulations implemented throughout the world to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, conquer global warming, and prevent climate change.

Categories
Climate Change Law Climate Change Laws Around the World

What Is the UK Doing to Stop Climate Change?

Greenhouse gasses, global warming, and catastrophic climate change have been subjects of controversy for decades, and time is running out, but the UK is making impressive strides in its efforts to protect the planet. 

Categories
Climate Change Law Climate Change Law & Policy Climate Change Laws Around the World Climate Change Legislation Climate Change Regulations Uncategorized

Is the Paris Agreement Legally Binding?

Since President Donald Trump formally began to withdraw from the 2015 Paris Agreement in 2019, the question of whether the agreement is legally binding has been up for debate.

Categories
Climate Change Law Climate Change Laws Around the World

What Is the US Doing to Stop Climate Change?

Although the Trump Administration formally began to withdraw from the 2015 Paris Agreement in April 2019, federal, regional, state, and local efforts to combat global warming remain strong.